About Us

Barrie & Simcoe County's
Premier Handmade Cookie Creations

With a custom cookie for every holiday and event imaginable! I specialize in creating one-of-a-kind custom cookie favours to compliment any occasion or event. Also available Custom Cookie Baskets. A truly homemade affair that began as gifts for family and friends. My cookies not only look fabulous with their hand-decorated designs, but taste incredibly delicious too.

"The name Too Pretty To Eat evolved from the recipients of these delectable cookies." - Mara Tiberio, Owner

I have a variety of flavours to choose from, classic flavours such as Vanilla, Chocolate, and Gingerbread. Specialty flavours include Lemon, Spice, Maple, Chocolate-Ginger, and Lavender to name a few. I am always searching and adding new flavours to my collection. I use all real, fresh ingredients with no added preservatives or artificial flavours. If you’re looking for anything out of the ordinary to give as gifts or special occasions, I would be happy to consult by phone and email, as well as, personally meeting with you to find the perfect custom design.

"Mara's cookies are too pretty to eat, but too delicious to stop. Go ahead and take a bite..."